Elijah Williams
With the first comic of the From the Ashes revival, X-Men #1, we are treated to a delightful return to the familiar. While it may not be groundbreaking in its originality, the comforting sense of déjà vu is a welcome respite from the tumultuous Krakoan Age.
At the heart of X-Men #1 is a fresh team of Mutant heroes, bravely defending a world that harbors fear and hatred towards them. Cyclops takes the helm as the field commander, leading the more battle-ready Mutants on daring missions. Meanwhile, Beast, the Base Director, oversees those Mutants whose talents are more suited to support roles. The narrative seamlessly alternates between Beast guiding a local sheriff through their base, and the field team confronting a new adversary known as “The Fourth School.”
The Fourth School, however, is the weakest link in X-Men #1. Portrayed as “a blend of Human, A.I. and mutant,” they bear a striking resemblance to the Reavers, the Prime Sentinels, and every other cyborg threat to Mutantkind. The only twist is their inexplicable manifestation of Mutant powers in adulthood.
X-Men #1 feels like a trip down memory lane, and that’s a good thing
It’s assumed that anyone picking up X-Men #1 is already well-acquainted with the extensive cast of characters. While this is likely true, it could potentially deter new readers. However, Jed MacKay skillfully unravels the recent history for newcomers.
Regrettably, X-Men #1 stumbles into the common pitfall of many ensemble comics. Most characters are barely defined beyond their powers and codenames. Psylocke is particularly short-changed in this aspect, though a past romance between Kid Omega and Temper is hinted at.
Thankfully, the comic’s shortcomings are balanced by the genuinely witty dialogue peppered throughout the issue. A standout moment involves Cyclops sarcastically “repeating things you already know” to Kid Omega, cleverly justifying some necessary exposition. The playful banter between the heroes will surely resonate with long-time X-Men aficionados.
The artwork by Ryan Stegman is equally impressive. Stegman’s style is richly detailed yet maintains a sleek simplicity. He is a master visual storyteller, ensuring the action transitions smoothly from panel to panel. The inks by J.P. Mayer and colors by Marte Garcia further enhance his work.
Overall, X-Men #1 doesn’t stray far from the beaten path in its debut issue. It teases a fresh start for Marvel’s Mighty Mutants, but doesn’t deviate much from the classic formula, save for a new base and a few new members. However, the comic feels more like a warm reunion than a daring new venture, and that is quite refreshing.
Grade: 4/5.
X-Men #1 is now available at comic shops everywhere.
